16 April 2010, NYT: Former N.S.A. Official Is Charged in Leaks Case
31 October 2009, NYT: Deal in Senate on Protecting News Sources
1 February 2008, NYT: Times Reporter Subpoenaed Over Source for Book
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/29/us/29justice.html
April 28, 2010
U.S. Subpoenas Times Reporter Over Book on C.I.A.
By CHARLIE SAVAGE
WASHINGTON -- The Obama administration is seeking to compel a writer to testify about his confidential sources for a 2006 book about the Central Intelligence Agency, a rare step that was authorized by Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr.
The author, James Risen, who is a reporter for The New York Times, received a subpoena on Monday requiring him to provide documents and to testify May 4 before a grand jury in Alexandria, Va., about his sources for a chapter of his book, "State of War: The Secret History of the C.I.A. and the Bush Administration." The chapter largely focuses on problems with a covert C.I.A. effort to disrupt alleged Iranian nuclear weapons research.
Mr. Risen referred questions to his lawyer, Joel Kurtzberg, a partner at Cahill Gordon & Reindel L.L.P., who said that Mr. Risen would not comply with the demand and would ask a judge to quash the subpoena.
"He intends to honor his commitment of confidentiality to his source or sources," Mr. Kurtzberg said. "We intend to fight this subpoena."
The subpoena comes two weeks after the indictment [1] of a former National Security Agency official on charges apparently arising from an investigation into a series of Baltimore Sun articles that exposed technical failings and cost overruns of several agency programs that cost billions of dollars.
The lead prosecutor in both investigations is William Welch II. He formerly led the Justice Department's public integrity unit, but left that position in October after its botched prosecution of Senator Ted Stevens of Alaska.
Matthew A. Miller, a Justice Department spokesman, declined to discuss the subpoena to Mr. Risen or to confirm its existence. "As a general matter, we have consistently said that leaks of classified information are a matter we take extremely seriously," he said.
Mr. Risen and a colleague won a Pulitzer Prize for a December 2005 New York Times article that exposed the existence of the National Security Agency's warrantless surveillance program. While many critics -- including Barack Obama, then a senator -- called that program illegal, the Bush administration denounced the article as a damaging leak of classified information and opened an investigation into its sources. No one has been indicted in that matter.
The second chapter in Mr. Risen's book provides a detailed description of the program. But Mr. Kurtzberg said the Justice Department was seeking information only about Mr. Risen's sources for the ninth chapter, which centers on the C.I.A.'s effort to disrupt Iranian nuclear research. That material did not appear in The Times.
The book describes how the agency sent a Russian nuclear scientist -- who had defected to the United States and was secretly working for the C.I.A. -- to Vienna in February 2000 to give plans for a nuclear bomb triggering device to an Iranian official under the pretext that he would provide further assistance in exchange for money. The C.I.A. had hidden a technical flaw in the designs.
The scientist immediately spotted the flaw, Mr. Risen reported. Nevertheless, the agency proceeded with the operation, so the scientist decided on his own to alert the Iranians that there was a problem in the designs, thinking they would not take him seriously otherwise.
Mr. Risen described the operation as reckless, arguing that Iranian scientists may have been able to "extract valuable information from the blueprints while ignoring the flaws." He also wrote that a C.I.A. case officer, believing that the agency had "assisted the Iranians in joining the nuclear club," told a Congressional intelligence committee about the problems, but that no action was taken.
It is not clear whether the Iranians had figured out that the Russian scientist had been working for the C.I.A. before publication of Mr. Risen's book.
The Bush administration had sought Mr. Risen's cooperation in identifying his sources for the Iran chapter of his book, and it obtained an earlier subpoena [2] against him in January 2008 under Attorney General Michael B. Mukasey. But Mr. Risen fought the subpoena, and never had to testify before it expired last summer. That left it up to Mr. Holder to decide whether to press forward with the matter by seeking a new subpoena.
If a judge does not agree to quash the subpoena and Mr. Risen still refuses to comply, he risks being held in contempt of court. In 2005, a Times reporter, Judith Miller, was jailed for 85 days for refusing to testify in connection with the Valerie Plame Wilson leak case.
Department rules [3] say prosecutors may seek such subpoenas only if the information they are seeking is essential and cannot be obtained another way, and the attorney general must personally sign off after balancing the public's interest in the news against the public's interest in effective law enforcement.
Congress is considering legislation [4] that would let judges make that determination, giving them greater power to quash subpoenas to reporters. The Obama administration supports such a media-shield bill, and the House of Representatives has passed a version of it. But a Senate version has been stalled for months.
[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/16/us/16indict.html
[2] http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/01/washington/01inquire.html
[3] http://cfr.vlex.com/vid/regard-toll-interrogation-indictment-19679461
[4] http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/31/us/politics/31shield.html